There are five arrangements a small business realistically uses: full-time permanent, part-time, fixed-term, casual or on-call, and independent contractor. Picking between them is not a paperwork decision. It sets what you are committed to paying, whether overtime and benefit rules apply, how easily the arrangement ends, and how much legal exposure you are carrying if you get the classification wrong.
The choice usually comes down to one question: is the work ongoing and under your direction, or is it finite and under someone else’s? Everything else follows from that.
Worth noting before you choose: hiring your first employee is also the moment the structure of the business itself comes back into play. Only 12.3% of small employers operate as sole proprietorships, against 86.7% of businesses with no employees, according to the SBA Office of Advocacy, which is to say that most owners reconsider their business structure at exactly the point they start putting people on contracts. And whichever of the five you pick, the document still needs the same core clauses every employment agreement carries: parties, duties, pay, confidentiality, termination.
The Bottom Line
- Of 161.9 million workers, 16.3 million (10.1%) held an alternative work arrangement as their main job, including 11.9 million independent contractors and 2.8 million on-call workers (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics).
- The Fair Labor Standards Act does not define full-time or part-time employment. That is the employer’s call (U.S. Department of Labor).
- Under the Affordable Care Act, anyone averaging 30 hours a week is full-time for coverage purposes regardless of what you call them (IRS).
- Independent contractor classification is in flux: the Department of Labor proposed rescinding the 2024 rule in February 2026 and has not finalised a replacement (Federal Register).
- Misclassifying an employee as a contractor is the costliest error on this list, and calling the document a contractor agreement does not make it one.
Metrobi drivers are rated 4.97/5
Trusted by local businesses for:
- Background-checked professionals
- Specialized in business deliveries
- Same drivers for consistency
- 4.97/5 average delivery rating
What an employment contract actually decides
Four things, and it is worth naming them because they are the levers you are actually pulling:
- Commitment. How long you owe the person work, and what it takes to end the arrangement.
- Cost structure. Whether the cost is fixed (salary) or variable (hours worked), and whether payroll taxes and benefits ride on top.
- Legal obligations. Overtime, minimum wage, workers’ compensation, unemployment insurance, benefit eligibility, paid leave entitlements.
- Control. How much you can direct when, where and how the work gets done, which is the hinge that separates an employee from a contractor.
Nothing about the title you give a role changes any of these. The facts of the arrangement do.
1. Full-time permanent contracts: the default for core roles
An open-ended contract with no end date, for someone working what your business treats as full hours.
Use it for the roles the business cannot run without: a head baker, a shop manager, a dispatcher, your lead driver. Anywhere continuity matters more than flexibility, and where you would rather invest in training someone than keep rehiring.
What it commits you to. A fixed, predictable cost whether this week is busy or dead. Payroll taxes, workers’ comp and unemployment insurance. Benefit eligibility, and if you have 50 or more full-time-equivalent employees, health coverage obligations.
The trade-off. Permanent staff are the expensive option per hour and the cheap option per unit of reliability. People on open-ended contracts stay longer, learn your operation and cover for each other, and the recruitment cost you are not paying every quarter is real money even if it never shows up as a line item.
Note that “full-time” has no legal hour threshold; the FLSA leaves it to you. But the ACA’s 30-hour test applies whatever you decide, so your internal definition is not the only definition in play.
2. Part-time contracts: predictable hours below full time
Also open-ended, also an employee, just fewer hours. The distinction from casual work is that the hours are agreed and regular.
Use it for steady work that does not fill a week: weekend shop cover, a morning prep shift, two delivery days, bookkeeping one day a week. It is also how you keep good people who need shorter hours rather than losing them.
What it commits you to. The same employee obligations as full-time, scaled: payroll taxes, workers’ comp, minimum wage and overtime rules once hours cross the weekly threshold. Benefit eligibility depends on your plan terms and on the 30-hour ACA line.
The trade-off. Flexibility for the business and stability for the worker, which is a rare combination. The failure mode is drift: a 20-hour contract where the person routinely works 34. At that point you have a full-time employee with part-time paperwork, including for ACA purposes. Fix the contract rather than letting the gap sit.
3. Fixed-term contracts: employment with an end date
An employee relationship that terminates on a stated date or on completion of a defined project.
Use it for work with a real horizon: the holiday season, a summer farmers’ market run, covering parental leave, a six-month push to launch a wholesale line, a one-off catering contract.
What it commits you to. Everything a permanent contract does for the duration. The difference is the exit: it is scheduled rather than negotiated, which is why you would use one. Ending it early still needs a termination clause, so write one.
The trade-off. Clean, honest and easy to staff for a known peak. Two cautions. First, do not use rolling fixed-term contracts to avoid making someone permanent; repeatedly renewing a term contract for the same ongoing role invites a finding that the role was never temporary. Second, say in writing what happens at the end date, whether it expires or converts to permanent on notice, because silence creates expectations.
4. Casual and on-call contracts: no guaranteed hours
Sometimes called a zero-hour contract. The person is an employee when they work, but you do not guarantee hours and they can usually decline a shift.
Use it for demand you cannot predict: event catering, a florist’s Valentine’s week, extra delivery capacity when a big order lands, holiday shop cover. BLS counted 2.8 million on-call workers in its most recent survey of alternative arrangements, so this is a substantial and normal category.
What it commits you to. Employee obligations on the hours actually worked: minimum wage, overtime, payroll taxes, usually workers’ comp. Not a guaranteed wage. Some states and cities add predictive scheduling rules requiring advance notice of shifts or premium pay for late changes, so check local law before you build an operation on this model.
The trade-off. Maximum flexibility, minimum reliability. People with no guaranteed hours take other work, and the week you most need them is often the week they are unavailable. Casual staff work best as a surge layer on top of a stable core, not as the core. Note too what workers themselves say: 44.8% of contingent workers told BLS they would have preferred a permanent job, which is a retention warning worth hearing.
5. Independent contractor agreements: not employment at all
A contractor runs their own business and sells you a service. This is a commercial contract, not an employment contract, and it belongs on a different document.
Use it for specialist or project work you do not direct: a bookkeeper, a designer, a photographer, an electrician, a consultant who sets their own methods and hours. BLS put independent contractors at 11.9 million workers, and 80.3% of them said they preferred the arrangement. This is a legitimate category when the facts support it.
What it commits you to. Agreed fees, and not much else. You withhold no payroll taxes and owe no overtime, benefits or unemployment insurance. The contractor handles their own taxes and insurance, and you issue a 1099 rather than a W-2.
Where the engagement is billed hourly rather than by project, settle up front how time gets recorded and reported with the invoice. Time-tracking tools built for consultants exist for exactly this, and the distinction that matters is whose records they are: a contractor keeping their own hours and billing against them is normal, whereas a timesheet you administer and approve starts to look like supervision.
What it does not let you do. Treat someone as a contractor while directing their work like an employee. Classification is decided on the economic reality of the relationship (how much control you exercise, whether the person has their own business and other clients, whether they supply their own tools, how permanent the arrangement is), not on what the contract says. The rules are also moving: the Department of Labor proposed in February 2026 to rescind its 2024 classification rule and restore an analysis close to its 2021 standard, and the replacement is not final (Federal Register). Several states apply stricter tests than the federal one regardless.
The five types of employment contracts compared
| Contract type | Guaranteed hours | Payroll taxes & overtime | Ends by | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full-time permanent | Yes, full schedule | Yes | Notice or termination | Core roles you can’t run without |
| Part-time | Yes, reduced schedule | Yes | Notice or termination | Steady work under a full week |
| Fixed-term | Yes, for the term | Yes | Stated date or project end | Seasons, cover, defined projects |
| Casual / on-call | No | Yes, on hours worked | Any time, by either side | Surge and unpredictable demand |
| Independent contractor | No | No | Contract terms | Specialist work you don’t direct |
How to choose the right employment contract for a role
Work through it in this order:
- Is the work ongoing or finite? Finite points to fixed-term. Ongoing points to permanent, full or part-time.
- Is demand predictable? Predictable supports guaranteed hours. Erratic demand supports casual, but be honest, because “unpredictable” often means “I haven’t forecast it”.
- Do you need to direct how the work is done? If yes, it is employment. That answer alone rules out a contractor agreement.
- Does the role need continuity, or just capacity? Continuity justifies the fixed cost of permanent staff. Pure capacity does not.
- Can the business carry the fixed cost through its slowest month? This is where the decision meets the numbers, and it belongs in the personnel line of your business financial plan rather than being settled on instinct during a busy week.
A practical pattern for most food, floral, catering and wholesale operations: a small permanent core, part-time contracts for the regular shoulder shifts, fixed-term for the season, casual for surges, contractors for specialist work. Mixing types deliberately beats forcing everything into one.
Misclassification is the expensive mistake
Of everything on this page, treating an employee as a contractor carries the biggest downside. The exposure includes back payroll taxes, unpaid overtime and minimum wage, unemployment and workers’ compensation contributions, penalties and interest, and in some states additional damages. It can surface years later through an unemployment claim, an injury, or a tax audit.
The signals that an arrangement has drifted into employment are consistent: you set the hours, you supply the tools and vehicle, the person works only for you, you direct the method rather than specifying the outcome, and the arrangement has no end. Any two of those together is worth a second look.
If you need someone on your schedule, using your equipment, doing what you tell them, hire them as an employee. The paperwork is heavier and it is the cheaper answer.
Written, verbal and implied contracts
Most of these arrangements can technically exist without a written document. An employment relationship can be formed verbally, and courts recognise implied terms from conduct and from documents like handbooks.
Put it in writing anyway. The written version is what sets the hours, the pay basis, the confidentiality obligation and the exit terms; without it, the default rules fill the gaps and they rarely fill them in your favour. Several states also require a written wage notice at hire, which is a separate obligation from the contract itself.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an employment contract and an employment agreement?
In everyday use, nothing; the terms are interchangeable. What differs is the function of the two documents in this cluster: the type of contract decides what kind of arrangement you are creating, and the agreement is the document that spells out its terms.
How many hours is part-time?
There is no legal definition federally. Common practice is under 30 or under 35 hours a week, but you set it. The number that is not yours to set is the ACA’s 30-hour threshold for health coverage.
Can I convert a fixed-term contract into a permanent one?
Yes, and it is a normal path for a seasonal hire who works out. Do it with a new written agreement rather than by letting the end date pass unmentioned, which leaves the terms ambiguous.
Do I need a different contract for delivery drivers?
Not a different type. Drivers can sit on any of the five. What they need is extra clauses: licence and insurance requirements, vehicle use, mileage reimbursement if they use their own car, and driving record checks. Classification deserves particular care here, since driver arrangements draw regulatory attention.
Which contract type is cheapest?
Per hour, a contractor. Overall, it depends entirely on whether the classification holds up, and an unsupportable contractor arrangement is the most expensive option on this page.
Choosing well
Start from the work, not from the cost. Describe the role honestly: how long it lasts, how predictable it is, how much you need to direct it. The right contract type is usually obvious by the end of the description.
Then write it down, keep the classification tests in mind for anyone you are treating as a contractor, and revisit the arrangement when the hours drift. Most contract problems in small businesses are not bad initial choices; they are good choices nobody updated.