The best payroll services for small business in 2026 fall into three price bands: self-service filing from about $17 a month, full-service payroll from about $29 to $50 a month plus $4 to $7 per employee, and PEO arrangements from about $79 per employee per month. Which band you belong in depends less on headcount than on how complicated your pay is.
This comparison is about services, meaning the providers that calculate, file and pay on your behalf, rather than software you operate yourself. If you have not settled whether to hand payroll over at all, start with the decision itself in outsourcing payroll for small business and come back once you know you want a provider.
One standing caveat, since prices are the thing readers most often arrive for: every figure below is a published list price checked in November 2026, and payroll vendors change pricing and plan names regularly. Treat these as a shortlist filter, then confirm on the provider’s own pricing page before you commit. Where a provider does not publish pricing, that is noted rather than estimated.
Key Takeaways
- OnPay publishes $40 a month plus $6 per employee with every state included, which makes it the simplest answer for a business filing in more than one state.
- Patriot’s Basic plan at $17 plus $4 does not file your taxes; Full Service at $37 plus $5 does. The difference is the part that carries penalty risk.
- ADP and Paychex do not publish small-business pricing, so any number you see quoted for them online is a user report, not a rate card.
- If you pay delivery drivers, the three features that matter are two pay rates on one employee, non-taxable mileage reimbursement, and filings in every state your routes reach.
Boost customer satisfaction with just a few clicks
Most-Loved Features:
- On-demand drivers
- Real-time GPS tracking
- Delivery confirmation photos
- Over 50% of customers report a smoother delivery experience
What counts as a payroll service
A payroll service takes responsibility for the pay cycle: gross-to-net calculation, withholding, direct deposit, tax deposits on the IRS and state schedules, quarterly 941s, year-end W-2s and 1099s. Most of them also carry a tax-filing guarantee, meaning they pay penalties caused by their own error.
That is different from payroll software you run, where the platform does the arithmetic and you stay responsible for pressing the buttons on time. It is also different from a PEO, which becomes a co-employer so you can buy into its group health and workers’ comp.
Two practical requirements sit underneath all of them. Direct deposit needs a business checking account the provider can debit, and if yours is still a personal account or a bank that charges for ACH batches, sorting that out first is worth the afternoon, and our rundown of the best banks for small business covers what to look for. Every pay run also has to produce an itemized stub showing hours, rates, gross, each deduction and net; providers generate these automatically, and employers patching gaps in old records sometimes end up rebuilding them with a pay stub generator instead, which is a sign the underlying records need attention.
Nearly every provider in the list below sells all of these as plan tiers of the same product, which is why the comparison turns on what is included rather than on brand.
How these payroll services were compared
Five criteria, weighted for a small business that has people and vehicles moving around:
- Published price, including the filing tier. Base fee plus per-employee fee for the cheapest plan that actually files your taxes.
- Multi-state handling. Whether additional states are included or surcharged, and whether the provider registers you or leaves that to you.
- Multiple pay rates per employee. Whether one person can hold a warehouse rate and a driving rate with overtime blended correctly across both.
- Mileage and reimbursements. Whether non-taxable reimbursement is a standard pay line rather than a workaround.
- Hours in. Whether the service includes time tracking or imports cleanly from the tool you already use. That matters more than feature lists suggest, and the mechanics are covered in our guide to time tracking for small businesses.
What is deliberately not weighted: HR add-ons, org charts, engagement surveys. They inflate plan tiers and rarely change a pay run.
Payroll services for small business at a glance
| Provider | Published price (filing tier) | States included | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patriot Full Service | $37/mo + $5 per worker | Federal, state and local filed | Tight budgets that still want filing done |
| SurePayroll Full Service | $29/mo + $7 per employee | Filed, with tax guarantee | Teams of one to four |
| OnPay | $40/mo + $6 per employee | All states, no surcharge | Routes crossing state lines |
| Gusto Simple | $49/mo + $6 per person | Single state on Simple; multi-state on Plus at $80 + $12 | Teams that want onboarding and benefits in one place |
| Square Payroll | $35/mo + $6 per person | Filed | Businesses already taking payments on Square |
| QuickBooks Payroll Core | $50/mo + $6 per person | Filed | Books already in QuickBooks |
| ADP RUN / Paychex | Not published; quote only | Included | Operations that want a named representative |
| Justworks PEO | $79 per employee/mo (Basic) | Included | Buying group health coverage |
Sources for published pricing: provider pricing pages and plan documentation, cross-checked against Forbes Advisor’s payroll service cost guide, November 2026. ADP and Paychex quote individually, so the row is left blank rather than guessed.
OnPay: the straightforward pick for multi-state payroll
OnPay publishes one plan at $40 a month plus $6 per employee, and the price covers payroll in every state with no per-state surcharge. For a business whose drivers cross a state line, that single fact often decides the shortlist, because the alternative is either a plan upgrade or a per-state fee that grows with your delivery radius.
Multiple pay rates per employee are supported, which covers the warehouse-rate-plus-driving-rate case. Ten employees land at $100 a month, twenty-five at $190. Predictable enough to budget a year ahead.
The trade-off is a plainer product. There is no deep benefits marketplace and the interface is functional rather than polished. If your priority is paying people correctly in three states without reading a pricing matrix, that is a fair exchange.
Gusto Simple: the better fit when you are hiring
Gusto’s Simple plan is $49 a month plus $6 per person and bundles the parts of employment that are not strictly payroll: offer letters, onboarding checklists, W-4 collection, document storage, and a benefits marketplace you can grow into.
The catch for delivery operations is multi-state. Simple covers a single state, and multi-state payroll sits on the Plus plan at $80 a month plus $12 per person. For a ten-person team that is $200 a month against OnPay’s $100 for the same filing coverage. If you operate in one state and hire regularly, Gusto earns the premium. If you operate in three, it is an expensive way to get there.
Patriot: the cheapest route to filed payroll taxes
Patriot sells two tiers and the gap between them is the whole point. Basic Payroll is $17 a month plus $4 per worker and does the calculations while leaving you to file and deposit. Full Service is $37 plus $5 and files and deposits federal, state and local taxes with a filing guarantee.
Anyone shopping on price should understand which of those they are buying. The $17 plan does not reduce your penalty exposure, because the deadlines remain yours. Late deposits draw a penalty of 2% to 15% of the amount depending on how late they are, which means one missed month can cost more than a year of the upgrade.
Patriot also bills in arrears and skips the per-employee charge in a month with no pay run, which suits businesses with a genuine off-season.
SurePayroll: built around very small teams
SurePayroll, a Paychex company, publishes Full-Service Payroll at $29 a month plus $7 per employee, with automatic filings, deposits, W-2s and a no-penalty tax filing guarantee. A self-service tier at $20 plus $4 drops the filing.
The per-employee rate is the highest in the full-service group, so the economics invert as you grow: at three employees it is the cheapest full-service option on this page, and by fifteen it is not. It is a good answer for an owner-operator with two or three staff who wants the filing handled and nothing else.
Square Payroll: worth it if you already run on Square
Square Payroll is $35 a month plus $6 per person and makes sense mainly for businesses already taking payments on Square, where timecards from the POS flow into payroll without a separate integration. For a bakery or florist with a counter and a couple of delivery runs, that is a genuine reduction in steps.
If you are not on Square, there is nothing here that OnPay does not do more cheaply across states.
QuickBooks Payroll Core: for books that already live in QuickBooks
QuickBooks Payroll Core is $50 a month plus $6 per person. It is the most expensive of the published-price group at the entry tier, and the argument for it is reconciliation rather than features: payroll journal entries land in your books without export, which saves your bookkeeper real time every month.
If your accountant already works in QuickBooks, ask them before deciding. Their preference is worth more than the $10 difference.
ADP RUN and Paychex: when you want a person to call
Neither ADP nor Paychex publishes small-business pricing; both quote per account. Figures circulating online for RUN, commonly cited around $79 a month plus a per-employee fee, come from user reports rather than a rate card, which is why this comparison does not put a number in the table.
What you are buying at that price is depth and a named representative: multi-state compliance, complex garnishments, HR support, and someone accountable when a state agency sends a letter. For a business with fifty-plus people across several states, that is a legitimate choice. For a ten-person operation with straightforward pay, it is more service than the problem requires.
Get quotes from both, ask specifically what happens at year-end renewal, and ask whether W-2 processing carries a separate charge.
Justworks and the PEO option
Justworks publishes PEO Basic at $79 per employee per month and PEO Plus at $124, with no base fee. Under a PEO you become a co-employer, which lets a ten-person business access group health insurance and workers’ comp rates it could not negotiate alone.
Read that pricing carefully against what you are buying. For payroll processing alone, $790 a month for ten people is indefensible against OnPay’s $100. For payroll plus genuinely competitive health coverage for ten people, it can be the cheapest total cost on the page. The decision is a benefits decision wearing payroll clothing. Justworks also sells a payroll-only product at $8 per employee plus a $50 base fee if the benefits piece is not what you need.
The option most roundups skip: a local bookkeeper
A bookkeeper or CPA firm running your payroll through their own software license is a real alternative, and for some operations the right one. Typical small-business engagements run a few hundred dollars a month, which looks expensive next to $100, until you count what else is in it.
What you get that software does not provide: someone who notices that a new hire’s classification looks wrong, that your mileage reimbursements have no backing log, or that you are about to owe in a state you have not registered in. Those are judgment calls, and they are exactly the ones that create the common small business payroll mistakes that no provider will catch for you.
The honest comparison is not bookkeeper versus software. It is bookkeeper versus software plus the hour a month you will spend reviewing it, and whether you will actually spend that hour.
What to check if you pay delivery drivers
Four questions to put to any provider on this list before signing. They are not edge cases if you run your own deliveries.
Can one employee hold two pay rates with overtime blended across them? Someone who packs at $18 and drives at $22 and works 46 hours needs overtime calculated on the weighted average of what they earned, not on one rate.
Is non-taxable mileage reimbursement a standard pay line? Reimbursement at or below the IRS rate stays out of taxable wages. For 2026 that rate is 72.5 cents per mile through June and 76 cents from July 1 (IRS, retrieved 2026-11-10). A provider that can only process it as taxable wages creates a tax problem for your drivers.
What does each additional state cost? Ask for the number, not “we support multi-state.” OnPay includes every state; Gusto puts it behind a plan tier; others charge per state per month.
Will hours import, and from what? If the answer is CSV only, find out what format. Retyping forty timecards defeats the purpose.
It is also worth knowing how the large carriers structure the same problem, since their pay codes are the mature version of what you are building. Breakdowns of how FedEx handles driver payroll show the separate lines for base hours, overtime and vehicle costs that your own setup eventually needs. One security note while you are setting up: your payroll login holds bank details and Social Security numbers for everyone on staff, so it belongs in a business password manager with two-factor authentication rather than in a browser profile shared with whoever covers the office.
Which payroll service should you choose?
- One to four employees, one state: SurePayroll Full Service at $29 + $7, or Patriot Full Service at $37 + $5 if you want local tax filing included.
- Five to twenty-five employees, one state, hiring regularly: Gusto Simple at $49 + $6.
- Any size, more than one state: OnPay at $40 + $6, because the states are included.
- Already on Square or QuickBooks: the matching product, for the integration rather than the price.
- Group health coverage is the real goal: a PEO, priced per employee.
- Pay structure keeps changing, or your books need attention: a bookkeeper, not a platform.
Whatever you pick, the monthly fee is the smaller half of the question. Employer taxes, reimbursements and your own time make up the rest, and the real small business payroll cost breakdown adds those up properly.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest payroll service for a small business?
Among providers that publish pricing and file your taxes, Patriot Full Service at $37 a month plus $5 per worker and SurePayroll Full Service at $29 plus $7 are the lowest entry points as of November 2026. Below that, you are buying calculation only and keeping the filing deadlines yourself.
Do payroll services handle multiple states?
All of the providers here can, but the pricing differs sharply. OnPay includes every state in its base price. Gusto requires the Plus plan for multi-state. Others charge a monthly fee per additional state. Ask for the per-state cost before you sign, because a growing delivery radius makes this bill grow with it.
Is a payroll service the same as payroll software?
No. Software you operate does the math and leaves the schedule to you. A payroll service files and deposits on your behalf and usually guarantees its own filings. Most vendors sell both as tiers of one product, and the tier name rarely makes the difference obvious, so check whether tax filing is included.
Can a payroll service pay contractors as well as employees?
Yes. Most include 1099 contractor payments, some at no extra charge and some per contractor per month. If you use subcontracted drivers alongside employees, confirm the contractor charge and confirm that 1099 filing in January is included rather than billed separately.
How long does it take to set up a payroll service?
Days for the processing itself, two to four weeks in practice. The delay is almost always state account verification: getting a withholding or unemployment account number for a state you have not filed in before. Start the paperwork before you need the first run.