Small business payroll cost has three layers, and the one everybody shops for is the smallest. Processing fees run about $40 a month plus $6 per employee. Employer taxes add roughly 8% to 10% on top of every dollar of wages. Your own time, at two to four hours a pay period, is the layer nobody puts on a spreadsheet and the one that most often decides whether the current arrangement is worth keeping.
Price all three and the picture changes. For a ten-person business paying average wages, the payroll service is around 0.3% of total payroll spend while the employer taxes are nearly thirty times that. Shopping hard on the $40 while ignoring a misclassified driver or an unlogged mileage allowance is optimizing the wrong line.
This breakdown walks each layer with real 2026 numbers, including the lines specific to a business that runs its own deliveries. For which provider to actually hire, see the comparison of payroll services for small business; for whether to hand payroll over at all, start with outsourcing payroll for small business.
Key Takeaways
- Processing is the cheap layer: about $40 a month plus $6 per employee, or roughly $1,200 a year for a team of ten.
- Employer payroll taxes are the expensive layer: 7.65% FICA plus FUTA and state unemployment, commonly 8% to 10% of gross wages combined.
- For 2026 the Social Security wage base is $184,500 and the FUTA wage base is still $7,000, so the two taxes behave very differently as wages rise.
- Mileage reimbursement is a cash cost that never appears in a payroll quote. One driver covering 200 miles a week costs about $7,900 a year at the 2026 IRS rate.
Save 80% of delivery management time
We handle everything:
- Dedicated operations manager
- Real-time tracking dashboard
- Automated customer notifications
- Urgent issue resolution
What a payroll service costs per month
Published list prices in November 2026, for the cheapest plan at each provider that actually files your taxes:
| Provider | Base per month | Per employee | Ten employees |
|---|---|---|---|
| SurePayroll Full Service | $29 | $7 | $99 |
| Patriot Full Service | $37 | $5 | $87 |
| OnPay | $40 | $6 | $100 |
| Gusto Simple | $49 | $6 | $109 |
| Square Payroll | $35 | $6 | $95 |
| QuickBooks Payroll Core | $50 | $6 | $110 |
The industry shorthand of roughly $40 a month plus $6 per employee holds up well against the actual rate cards (Forbes Advisor, retrieved 2026-11-10). A ten-person operation should expect $85 to $110 a month, or about $1,000 to $1,320 a year.
Two things reliably push the real bill above the quote. Multi-state payroll is often a plan upgrade or a per-state monthly fee, so a second state can add more than a second employee. And year-end form processing is sometimes charged per W-2 or per 1099, which shows up as a January surprise. Ask about both in the sales conversation, not after.
Employer payroll taxes in 2026
This is the layer that actually moves money, and it is owed whoever processes your payroll.
FICA: 7.65% matched by the employer. That is 6.2% for Social Security plus 1.45% for Medicare, matching what you withhold from the employee. For 2026 the Social Security wage base is $184,500, up from $176,100 (IRS Publication 15, retrieved 2026-11-10). The Medicare portion has no ceiling.
FUTA: 6% on the first $7,000, usually reduced to 0.6%. Employers who pay state unemployment on time generally claim a 5.4% credit, leaving $42 per employee per year in most states. The wage base has not moved, so FUTA is effectively a small fixed cost per head.
State unemployment: the variable one. Rates and wage bases are set by each state and by your own claims history, which is why a national average is close to useless. A new employer rate of 2% to 4% on a wage base somewhere between $7,000 and $60,000 covers most of the range. Look yours up; it is the line most likely to surprise you.
Workers’ compensation. Not technically a payroll tax, but it behaves like one on your cash flow and it is priced by job classification. Delivery driving classifies higher than clerical work, sometimes several times higher, so an operation that puts staff in vehicles pays materially more per wage dollar than a shop that does not.
What payroll costs a ten-person business, line by line
A worked example, deliberately conservative: ten employees, average wages of $45,000, total gross payroll of $450,000 a year.
| Cost line | Annual | Share of gross payroll |
|---|---|---|
| Employer FICA at 7.65% | $34,425 | 7.65% |
| FUTA at 0.6% on first $7,000 each | $420 | 0.09% |
| State unemployment, illustrative 2.7% on a $12,000 base | $3,240 | 0.72% |
| Payroll service at $40 + $6 per employee | $1,200 | 0.27% |
| Total above wages, before workers’ comp | $39,285 | 8.73% |
Workers’ comp sits on top and varies too much by state and classification to average honestly; for a business with drivers it is commonly the fourth-largest line here rather than a rounding error.
Benefits are the layer after this one and they are larger than most owners expect, which is why they get their own accounting in our breakdown of the cost of employee benefits for small business owners. Your own compensation is a separate question again: how much an owner takes as salary against distributions changes both the payroll tax bill and the personal tax position, and once the numbers get large enough it stops being a payroll decision and becomes one for an accountant or a wealth planning advisor who works with business owners.
The ratio is the point. The payroll service is 3% of the cost of running payroll. The taxes are 97%. Which means the money in payroll administration is not in negotiating the fee. It is in getting the taxable amounts right, because those are the numbers the 97% is calculated from.
The cost of running payroll yourself
The DIY option is not free, it is just unbilled.
At two to four hours per pay period on a biweekly schedule, payroll consumes 52 to 104 hours a year. Put your own hourly value against that, not minimum wage but what an hour of your attention is worth to the business, and compare the result to $1,200. For most owners the comparison is not close, and it gets worse as the team grows.
Then there are the costs that only appear when something goes wrong:
- Late deposit penalties run 2% of the amount for deposits one to five days late, 5% at six to fifteen days, 10% beyond that, and 15% once the IRS has issued a notice and ten days pass.
- Corrected returns. A 941-X is a few hours of your bookkeeper’s time plus any interest on the underpayment.
- Back pay and liquidated damages from overtime calculated wrong, which for a driver with two pay rates is an easy mistake to make quietly for a year.
- Reissued W-2s in February, which cost little in money and a surprising amount in goodwill.
None of these are certainties. All of them are priced at zero in a spreadsheet that compares $0 of DIY to $1,200 of service, which is how that comparison keeps producing the wrong answer. The specific failure modes are catalogued in 5 common small business payroll mistakes to avoid.
Payroll costs specific to running your own deliveries
Four lines that a payroll quote will never mention and that a delivery operation pays every month.
Mileage reimbursement. If drivers use their own vehicles, you reimburse. At the 2026 IRS business rate of 72.5 cents per mile through June and 76 cents from July 1 (IRS, retrieved 2026-11-10), a driver covering 200 miles a week costs roughly $7,900 a year in reimbursement alone. It is non-taxable when it is at or below the IRS rate and properly logged, which makes it cheaper than paying the equivalent as wages, but it is still cash leaving the account.
Blended overtime. An employee who packs at $18 and drives at $22 does not get overtime at either rate. It is calculated on the weighted average of what they actually earned that week, which lands between the two and is almost always higher than whatever a manual calculation guessed.
Multi-state filing fees. Every state your routes regularly reach can mean another registration, another filing, and with some providers another monthly charge. It is the cost line that argues most clearly for using local drivers in each market you serve rather than extending routes across a border. A Burlington, Vermont delivery service handling that corner of your map keeps the driver, and the filing obligation, inside one state.
Unproductive paid time. Waiting at a supplier, sitting in traffic, the twenty minutes of loading before the clock officially starts. All of it is compensable, all of it is payroll cost, and it is invisible unless you capture it, which is the argument for proper time tracking for small businesses rather than estimates at the end of the week.
How to work out what payroll should cost you
Allow about an hour, with your last quarter’s figures to hand.
- Total gross wages for the quarter from your last 941, annualized.
- Add employer taxes: 7.65% of gross wages, plus $42 per employee for FUTA, plus your actual state unemployment rate applied to your state’s wage base.
- Add workers’ comp premium at your real classification rates, not an average.
- Add reimbursements: mileage, vehicle allowances, phone stipends.
- Add your own hours at a defensible hourly value, or your bookkeeper’s billed time.
The total is your payroll cost. Divide it by revenue and you have a number worth tracking quarter to quarter. Industry benchmarks for payroll as a share of revenue get quoted freely and vary so widely by sector that your own trend line is more useful than any published figure. A kitchen or a florist runs labor-heavy; an equipment-led business is the opposite, which is most of the appeal in asking whether a laundromat is a good investment: the machines work unpaid. Comparing your ratio to a business with a different capital structure tells you nothing useful.
Is paying for payroll worth it?
For almost every business past its second employee, yes, but the reason is not the one in the sales material.
The time saving is real and modest: perhaps forty hours a year back. The actual value is that filing deadlines stop depending on your attention during your busiest week. Payroll deadlines do not move for a delivery surge, a supplier problem, or a van off the road, and the weeks when you are most likely to miss one are exactly the weeks when a provider is still filing on time.
At roughly $100 a month against $39,000 of taxes and wages that must be calculated and remitted correctly, the fee is insurance priced at a quarter of a percent of the exposure. The useful question is not whether to pay it but whether the provider you chose can handle two rates on one employee and every state your drivers reach, which is what the payroll services comparison is for.
Frequently asked questions
How much does payroll cost per employee per month?
Processing runs $4 to $12 per employee per month on top of a base fee, with most small-business plans at $5 to $7. Including employer taxes, the full cost of employing someone is roughly 9% to 12% above their wages before benefits, driven mainly by the 7.65% FICA match and workers’ compensation.
What percentage of revenue should payroll be?
It varies enough by sector that a single benchmark misleads more than it helps. Labor-intensive operations run far higher than asset-heavy ones. Track your own ratio quarterly and watch the direction of travel; a rising ratio with flat revenue is the signal worth acting on.
Are payroll fees tax deductible?
Yes. Payroll service fees are an ordinary and necessary business expense, as are the employer portions of FICA, FUTA and state unemployment. Mileage reimbursements paid at or below the IRS rate are deductible to the business and non-taxable to the employee, which is the most efficient way to handle vehicle costs.
Why is my payroll bill higher than the advertised price?
Three usual causes: a second state pushed you into a higher plan tier or added a per-state fee, contractor payments are billed per 1099 on top of per-employee charges, or year-end W-2 and 1099 processing carries a separate charge. All three are worth confirming before signing rather than discovering in January.
Is it cheaper to run payroll in-house?
Only in cash terms, and only when payroll is genuinely simple: one or two salaried people, one state, no overtime. Once hours vary, rates blend, or a route crosses a state line, the hours you spend plus the probability of a penalty exceed the fee comfortably.