Common causes of employee turnover at small businesses

Employee turnover is a silent killer for small businesses.

It drains resources, disrupts productivity, and erodes team morale. The costs are staggering: For every employee lost, you’ll spend 33% of their annual salary finding and training a replacement.

But here’s the good news: Most of the causes are preventable if you know where to look.

In this article, we’ll uncover the 7 most common reasons of employee turnover at small businesses, and give you proven strategies to keep your best talent on board.

Metrobi drivers are rated 4.97 out of 5

"Your delivery drivers actually show up on time and handle products carefully"

— Rachel Parkhurst, Boloco

Trusted by local businesses for:

• Background-checked professionals
• Specialized in business deliveries
• Same drivers for consistency
• 4.97/5 average delivery rating

Request a Callback Learn more

What Are the Main Causes of High Employee Turnover at Small Businesses?

• Low employee satisfaction, lack of engagement, and poor workplace culture are key drivers of high turnover

• Inadequate compensation, limited growth opportunities, and work-life imbalance also contribute to employee attrition

• The most common cause of employee turnover is often a combination of multiple factors rather than a single issue

Low Employee Satisfaction

Employee satisfaction plays a crucial role in understanding employee turnover and retention. When employees feel their expectations and needs are not being met, they are more likely to seek opportunities elsewhere. This can stem from various factors such as:

• Unmet expectations regarding job responsibilities, workload, or the overall work environment

• Lack of recognition and appreciation for their contributions and efforts

• Inadequate support from management or lack of resources to perform their jobs effectively

A study by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) found that 89% of employees who left their jobs cited lack of appreciation as a key reason for their departure. It’s essential for small businesses to regularly assess employee satisfaction through surveys, one-on-one meetings, and open communication channels to identify and address any issues promptly.

To boost employee satisfaction, small businesses can: Additionally, small businesses should consider exploring available financial incentives that can help them retain their talent. One such incentive is the potential for Employee Retention Credits, which can provide significant tax savings for businesses that maintain their workforce during challenging times.

1. Clearly communicate expectations and provide regular feedback

2. Implement employee recognition programs to acknowledge and reward outstanding performance

3. Foster open communication and encourage employees to share their concerns and ideas

4. Provide adequate resources and support to enable employees to perform their jobs effectively

Lack of Employee Engagement

Engaged employees are more committed, productive, and less likely to leave their jobs. However, when employees feel disengaged, they may start to explore other employment opportunities. Lack of engagement in new employee can result from:

• Monotonous or unchallenging work that fails to utilize their skills and abilities

• Feeling disconnected from the company’s goals and vision

• Limited opportunities for growth and development

According to Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace report, only 15% of employees worldwide are actively engaged in their jobs. Small businesses must prioritize employee engagement by providing meaningful work, setting clear goals, and offering opportunities for professional development.

To keep recruitment costs and improve employee engagement, small businesses can:

1. Assign tasks that align with employees’ strengths and interests

2. Communicate the company’s mission and how each employee’s role contributes to its success

3. Provide regular training and development opportunities to help employees grow and advance in their careers

4. Encourage employee participation in decision-making processes and value their input

Poor Workplace Culture

A positive workplace culture is essential for employee retention. When employees experience a toxic or unsupportive work environment, they are more likely to leave. Poor workplace culture can manifest in various ways, such as:

• Conflicts with coworkers or management that remain unresolved

• Lack of trust, respect, or collaboration among team members

• Discrimination, harassment, or bias in the workplace

A study by the Kapor Center found that 37% of employees who left their jobs in tech cited unfairness or mistreatment as the primary reason for their departure. Small businesses must foster a positive and inclusive workplace culture that values diversity, encourages open communication, and promotes teamwork.

To create a positive workplace culture, small businesses can:

1. Establish clear policies and procedures to address conflicts and promote respectful behavior

2. Provide diversity and inclusion training to create a welcoming environment for all employees

3. Encourage team-building activities and regular social interactions to foster camaraderie

4. Lead by example and demonstrate the values and behaviors expected from employees

Inadequate Compensation and Limited Growth Opportunities

Inadequate compensation and limited growth opportunities can also contribute to high employee turnover. Small businesses must ensure that they offer competitive salaries and benefits, as well as opportunities for professional development and advancement.

To address compensation and growth, small businesses can:

1. Conduct market research to ensure salaries are competitive

2. Offer performance-based bonuses and incentives

3. Provide opportunities for professional development and training

4. Create clear career paths and opportunities for advancement

Work-Life Imbalance

Work-life imbalance can also lead to high employee turnover. Small businesses must prioritize employee well-being by promoting a healthy work-life balance.

To promote work-life balance, small businesses can: Implementing a straightforward time off request form can streamline the process for employees and encourage them to take necessary breaks, ultimately fostering a healthier work-life balance.

Utilizing a simple time off request form can significantly enhance the scheduling process, ensuring that employees feel comfortable and supported when needing time away from work, thus further promoting their overall well-being and work-life balance.

1. Offer flexible work arrangements such as telecommuting or flexible hours

2. Encourage employees to take breaks and use their paid time off

3. Provide access to employee assistance programs (EAPs) for mental health and wellness support

4. Foster an open-door policy where employees feel comfortable discussing their work-life balance needs

By addressing these key causes of high employee turnover, small businesses can reduce attrition rates and create a more positive and productive work environment.

How Compensation and Benefits Impact Employee Turnover

Uncompetitive Salaries

When small businesses fail to align their wages with industry standards, they struggle to attract and retain skilled employees. A 2021 survey by Joblist found that 35% of job seekers cited low pay as their primary reason for leaving a job. This highlights the critical role competitive salaries play for small business owners in reducing employee turnover.

Offering salaries that are below market rates can lead to a revolving door of employees, as they seek better opportunities elsewhere. This not only disrupts the workflow but also more employee departures and increases the cost of recruiting, hiring, and training new staff. A 2020 study by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) revealed that the average cost-per-hire is $4,129, with an average time to fill a position of 42 days.

To ensure competitive salaries, small businesses should conduct regular salary benchmarking. This involves researching and comparing wages for similar positions within the same industry and location. Resources like Glassdoor, PayScale, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics can provide valuable insights into current salary trends.

Inadequate Benefits Packages

In addition to salaries, benefits packages play a crucial role in employee retention. A lack of essential benefits, such as health insurance, retirement plans, or paid time off, can drive employees to seek better offers elsewhere.

Small businesses that struggle to provide extensive benefits packages can explore creative alternatives, such as flexible work arrangements, professional development opportunities, or wellness programs. These non-traditional benefits can demonstrate a commitment to employee well-being and help offset the impact of limited traditional benefits.

When small businesses do offer a competitive benefits package, it’s essential to communicate their value effectively to employees. Regular benefits reviews and educational sessions can help employees understand and appreciate the full scope of their compensation package.

By addressing uncompetitive salaries and inadequate benefits, small businesses can significantly reduce employee turnover and foster a more stable, engaged workforce. This, in turn, can lead to increased productivity, improved customer satisfaction, and long-term business success.

The Role of Career Development in Employee Retention

Limited Growth Opportunities

When employees feel stuck in their roles with no clear path for advancement, they are more likely to seek opportunities elsewhere. A study by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) found that 32% of employees cited lack of career advancement opportunities as a top reason for leaving their job.

Small businesses may struggle to provide traditional career ladders due to their size and structure. However, they can still offer growth opportunities through:

Lateral Moves:

Allowing employees to take on new responsibilities or projects in different areas of the company can provide a sense of growth and development, even if a promotion isn’t possible.

Skill Development:

Encouraging employees to acquire new skills related to their role or the company’s goals can make them feel valued and invested in their career growth within when employees leave the organization.

Inadequate Training and Support

When employees don’t receive sufficient onboarding or ongoing training, they may struggle to perform their duties effectively, leading to frustration and disengagement. A Gallup study revealed that only 12% of employees strongly agree that their organization does a great job onboarding new hires. Empower your workforce by implementing cost-effective strategies for small business staff training, ensuring they are competent and motivated.

Small businesses can improve retention by:

• Develop a structured onboarding program that includes job shadowing, mentorship, and clear expectations to help new hires acclimate to their roles and the company culture.

• Invest in regular training sessions, workshops, or online courses to help employees expand their skill sets and stay up-to-date with industry trends. This shows a commitment to their professional development and can boost job satisfaction.

Mentorship and Coaching

Providing employees with mentorship and coaching opportunities can help them feel supported in their career growth and navigate challenges more effectively. A study by Deloitte found that retention rates were 25% higher for employees who had engaged in company-sponsored mentorship.

Small businesses can implement mentorship programs by:

• Match experienced employees with newer hires to provide guidance, support, and knowledge sharing. This can foster a sense of community and help junior employees feel more connected to the company.

• Offer coaching sessions for high-potential employees to develop their leadership skills and prepare them for future roles within the company. This investment in their growth can improve retention and create a pipeline of future leaders.

By prioritizing career development, small businesses can improve employee retention rates, boost job satisfaction, and create a more engaged workforce. Even with limited resources, implementing low-cost strategies such as lateral moves, skill development, and mentorship programs can make a significant impact on reducing turnover rates.

Work-Life Balance and Its Effect on Employee Turnover

Inflexible Work Schedules

Rigid work schedules that don’t allow for personal commitments or unexpected events can quickly lead to employee burnout and dissatisfaction. When employees are consistently required to work long hours or excessive overtime, they may feel that their personal lives are being neglected, leading to increased stress and a higher likelihood of seeking employment elsewhere.

According to a 2022 study by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), 48% of employees cited work-life balance as a key factor in their decision to leave a job. This highlights the importance of offering flexible work arrangements, such as adjustable start and end times or compressed workweeks, to accommodate employees’ personal needs and reduce turnover.

Burnout, often caused by prolonged periods of stress and overwork, can have a devastating effect on employee retention. A 2021 survey by Deloitte found that 77% of respondents had experienced burnout at their current job, with 91% stating that unmanageable stress or frustration negatively impacted the quality of their work.

When employees reach a state of burnout, they have lost productivity and are more likely to seek employment elsewhere in search of a better work-life balance. Small businesses that fail to address the root causes of burnout, such as excessive workloads and inflexible schedules, risk losing valuable talent to competitors that prioritize employee well-being.

Lack of Remote Work Options

In today’s increasingly digital world, many employees are seeking greater flexibility in where and how they work. The COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the shift towards remote work, with a significant portion of the workforce experiencing the benefits of working from home firsthand.

The Role of Company Culture in Promoting Work-Life Balance

A company culture that prioritizes work-life balance can play a crucial role in reducing employee turnover. When employees feel that their personal lives are valued and supported by their employer, they are more likely to remain loyal and engaged.

Small businesses can foster a culture of work-life balance by encouraging open communication, setting clear boundaries between work and personal time, and modeling healthy work habits from the top down. By regularly soliciting employee feedback and addressing concerns related to work-life balance, small businesses can proactively identify and resolve issues before they lead to turnover.

Investing in a company culture that promotes work-life balance can yield significant benefits for small businesses, beyond just reducing employee turnover. A 2021 study by the Harvard Business Review found that employees who feel their work-life balance is supported by their employer are 21% more likely to stay with the company long-term.

Strategies for Improving Employee Satisfaction and Retention

Conduct Regular Employee Surveys and Feedback Sessions

Regularly gathering feedback from your employees is essential for identifying areas of improvement within your organization. As Dr. Tracy Maylett, CEO of DecisionWise, explains, “Employee engagement surveys provide a powerful tool for understanding the employee experience and driving meaningful change.”

Employee surveys can help you pinpoint specific issues that may be contributing to high turnover rates. These could include:

• Inadequate communication from management

• Lack of recognition for achievements

• Limited opportunities for growth and development

• Poor work-life balance

• Insufficient training and development opportunities

• Unclear expectations and roles

By actively seeking feedback and acting upon it, you demonstrate to your employees that their opinions matter. This can lead to increased job, increase employee satisfaction and a greater sense of ownership in the company’s success.

Offer Competitive Compensation and Benefits Packages

Fair compensation and comprehensive benefits are essential for attracting and retaining top talent. As stated by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), “Compensation and benefits play a critical role in an employee’s overall satisfaction with their employer.”

Regularly review your employee’s annual salary and compensation structure to ensure it aligns with industry benchmarks. According to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median annual wage for all occupations in the United States was $47,672 as of May 2022. This can help prevent employees from leaving for higher-paying positions elsewhere.

Offering robust health insurance coverage and retirement savings options to retain employees shows your commitment to your employees’ well-being, both now and in the future. This can be a significant factor in employee retention.

Invest in Employee Training and Development

Providing opportunities for professional growth and skill development is a key strategy for improving employee satisfaction and retention. As noted by LinkedIn’s 2019 Workforce Learning Report, “94% of employees say they would stay at a company longer if it invested in their learning and development.”

Implement training programs, workshops, and mentorship initiatives to help employees expand their skill sets and advance within the company. This investment in their professional development can foster a sense of loyalty and engagement.

Clearly communicate the potential career trajectories available to employees within your organization. By offering visible paths for advancement, you give your team members a reason to stay and grow with the company.

Foster a Positive Workplace Culture

Creating a positive, supportive work environment is essential for employee satisfaction and retention. As Arianna Huffington, founder of Thrive Global, states, “A company’s culture is the foundation for future innovation. An entrepreneur’s job is to build the foundation.”

Foster a culture of open communication, where employees feel comfortable sharing ideas, concerns, and feedback. Encourage collaboration and teamwork to build strong relationships among colleagues.

Regularly acknowledge and celebrate employee successes, both big and small. This can include public recognition, bonuses, or other rewards that show your appreciation for their hard work and dedication.

Promote Work-Life Balance

Ensuring that your employees maintain a healthy work-life balance is crucial for reducing stress, preventing burnout, and improving overall job satisfaction. As stated by the WHO, “A good work-life balance is key to physical and mental health at work, as well as productivity and job satisfaction.”

When possible, provide employees with the flexibility to adjust their work hours or work remotely. This can help them better manage their personal and professional responsibilities, leading to increased job satisfaction.

Promote a culture that values and encourages the use of vacation time and personal days. Ensure that employees feel supported in taking the time they need to recharge and attend to personal matters.

By implementing these strategies, small businesses can significantly improve employee satisfaction and retention, leading to a more stable, productive, and successful organization.

The Benefits of Reducing Employee Turnover for Small Businesses

Lower Hiring and Training Costs

Reducing employee turnover can significantly lower the expenses associated with recruiting, hiring, and training new employees. The cost of replacing an employee can range from 50% to 200% of their annual salary, depending on the position and industry. These costs include advertising job openings, conducting interviews, background checks, onboarding, and training new hires. Seeking ways to cut down on turnover? Discover strategies and insights to refine your small business’s hiring process effectively.

By retaining experienced and talented employees, small businesses can save substantial amounts of money and time that would otherwise be spent on the hiring process. Additionally, long-term employees possess valuable institutional knowledge and expertise, which can be costly and time-consuming to replace.

Increased Productivity and Profitability

Maintaining a skilled and experienced workforce is crucial for small businesses to improve overall performance and success. High employee turnover can lead to decreased productivity, as new hires often require time to learn their roles and reach full productivity levels.

On the other hand, long-term employees have a deep understanding of the company’s processes, products, and customers, enabling them to work more efficiently and effectively. They can also serve as mentors to new hires, helping them adapt to the company culture and job responsibilities more quickly.

Improved Employee Morale and Engagement

High employee turnover can negatively impact the morale and engagement of the remaining employees and workforce. When colleagues frequently leave the company, it can create a sense of instability and uncertainty among the team, leading to decreased job satisfaction and motivation.

Conversely, reducing turnover and promoting long-term employee retention can foster a more positive and supportive work environment. Employees who feel valued and appreciated are more likely to be engaged, motivated, and committed to their roles and the company’s success.

Enhanced Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty

Reducing employee turnover can also lead to improved customer satisfaction and loyalty. Long-term employees often develop strong relationships with customers, understanding their needs and preferences on a deeper level. This knowledge allows them to provide better service and support, resulting in higher customer satisfaction and loyalty.

In contrast, high turnover can lead to inconsistent customer experiences, as new employees may lack the expertise and familiarity with the company’s products or services. This can result in decreased customer satisfaction and a higher likelihood of customers taking their business elsewhere.

Stronger Company Culture and Reputation

A company with high employee turnover can develop a negative reputation in the job market and the broader community. Prospective employees may view the company as an undesirable place to work, making it more challenging to attract top talent.

On the other hand, a company with low employee turnover costs and a reputation for valuing its employees can become an employer of choice, attracting highly skilled and motivated candidates. This positive reputation can also extend to customers and partners, enhancing the company’s overall brand image.

Implementing Effective Employee Engagement Strategies

Communicate Company Goals and Values

Clearly communicating your company’s goals and values to employees is crucial for fostering a sense of purpose and belonging. When employees understand how their individual roles contribute to the overall success of the organization, they feel more invested in their work and motivated to perform at their best.

To effectively communicate company goals and values:

• Schedule regular team meetings to discuss company goals, progress, and any changes or updates. Encourage employees to ask questions and provide feedback during these meetings.

• Highlight specific examples of how employees’ work has contributed to the company’s success. Share these stories in company newsletters, emails, or during team meetings to reinforce the importance of each employee’s role.

• When conducting performance reviews, discuss how employees have demonstrated the company’s values in their work. This reinforces the importance of these values and encourages employees to continue embodying them in their daily tasks.

Encourage Employee Involvement in Decision-Making

Involving employees in decision-making processes can significantly boost engagement and job satisfaction. When employees feel that their opinions and ideas are valued, they are more likely to take ownership of their work and feel invested in the company’s success.

To encourage employee involvement in decision-making:

• Actively seek input and feedback from employees on various topics, such as process improvements, new initiatives, or workplace policies. Use surveys, suggestion boxes, or one-on-one meetings to gather their thoughts and ideas.

• Create employee-led committees to address specific issues or projects within the company. This allows employees to take on leadership roles and contribute to important decisions that affect their work environment.

• When employees provide valuable suggestions or ideas, make an effort to implement them whenever possible. Acknowledge the employee’s contribution and explain how their idea has positively impacted the company.

By implementing these employee engagement strategies, small businesses can create a positive work environment that encourages open communication, collaboration, and a strong sense of purpose. When employees feel valued and invested in their work, they are more likely to remain with the company long-term, reducing turnover rates and boosting overall productivity.

Reducing Turnover: The Key to Small Business Success

High employee turnover can be costly and disruptive for small businesses. Low employee satisfaction, lack of engagement, poor workplace culture, uncompetitive compensation, and limited career development opportunities are among the most common causes of employee turnover at small businesses.

To improve employee retention strategies, small businesses should prioritize employee satisfaction by conducting regular surveys and feedback sessions, offering competitive salaries and benefits, investing in training and development, fostering a positive workplace culture, and promoting work-life balance.

By implementing effective employee engagement and retention strategies, such as communicating company goals and values and encouraging employee involvement in decision-making, small businesses can create a more motivated and loyal workforce.

In addition, utilizing tools like an employee evaluation form can help gather crucial feedback that promotes open communication and fosters employee growth.

The benefits of reducing employee turnover are clear: lower hiring and training costs, increased productivity, and improved overall business performance.