Are you leaving money on the table with your restaurant menu? In 2024, you can’t afford to. With rising costs and increasing competition, every dollar counts.
The good news? There are proven restaurant menu ideas and hacks that can skyrocket your average order value. And we’re not talking about gimmicks or tricks. These are tried-and-true strategies used by the most profitable restaurants in the business. Unlock the secrets to a top-tier dining menu and explore the indispensable elements that can make your offering irresistible to customers.
In this article, we’ll reveal 10 menu engineering secrets that will help you:
Boost sales of your most profitable dishes
Encourage customers to spend more per visit
Streamline your menu for maximum impact
Ready to unlock the hidden potential of your restaurant menu? Let’s dive in.
Metrobi has been a game changer for catering industry.
With Metrobi, you can save 23% on delivery costs, save 80% of the time from managing deliveries, and delight your customers with delivery notifications & tracking.
Menu Engineering 101: How to Design High-Profit Restaurant Menus
Analyze Your Menu Items’ Profitability and Popularity
To create a high-profit menu, you first need to understand how each menu item performs in terms of profitability and popularity of fast food restaurants. This process involves categorizing your dishes into four main groups: Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles, and Dogs.
Categorizing Menu Items
Stars: These are menu items with high profitability and popularity. They are the backbone of your menu and should be prominently featured and promoted.
Plowhorses: These items are popular among customers but have low profitability. While they may not contribute significantly to your bottom line, they are essential for attracting and retaining customers.
Puzzles: These dishes have high profitability but low popularity. They present an opportunity for improvement through better promotion, placement, or slight recipe modifications to increase their appeal.
Dogs: These items have both low profitability and low popularity. Consider removing them from your menu or re-engineering them to improve their performance.
To categorize your menu items, follow these steps:
Calculate the cost and profit margin for each dish
Analyze sales data to determine the popularity of each item
Plot each item on a matrix with profitability on one axis and popularity on the other
Identify which category each item falls into based on its position on the matrix
Optimizing Your Menu Based on Categorization
Once you have categorized your menu items, focus on branding, promoting, and optimizing your Stars and Puzzles. These dishes have the highest potential to increase your average order value and overall profitability.
Consider the following strategies:
Prominently feature Stars on your menu and in promotions
Train staff to suggest Stars and Puzzles to customers
Experiment with pricing, presentation, and descriptions to boost the popularity of Puzzles
Regularly review and update your menu based on performance data
Use the Golden Triangle and Eye Scanning Patterns
The placement of items on your menu can significantly impact their sales. By understanding how customers naturally scan a menu, you can strategically position high-profit items to maximize their visibility and appeal.
The Golden Triangle
The Golden Triangle refers to the area on a menu where customers’ eyes naturally gravitate first. This area typically includes the center of the printed menu first, then moves to the top right corner, and finally to the top left corner, forming a triangle.
To take advantage of the Golden Triangle:
Place your most profitable and popular items (Stars) in the center of your menu
Feature high-profit items or specials in the top right corner
Use the top left corner for items you want to showcase or upsell
Eye Scanning Patterns
In addition to the Golden Triangle, consider how customers naturally scan a menu. Most people follow a “Z” pattern, starting at the top left, moving across to the right, then down and to the left, and finally across to the right again.
To optimize your menu for eye-scanning patterns:
Place important information, such as your restaurant name or logo, at the top of the menu
Use visual cues, such as boxes, italics, or bold text, to draw attention to specific items
Create a logical flow for your menu categories, starting with appetizers and ending with desserts
Use white space strategically to make your menu easy to read and navigate
By analyzing your menu items’ profitability and popularity, and using the Golden Triangle and eye-scanning patterns to place high-profit items strategically, you can create a menu that drives sales and increases your average order value. Continuously monitor and adjust your menu based on performance data to ensure ongoing success.
Delivery notifications and tracking improve customer satisfaction by 27%.
Metrobi automatically notifies your receivers of ETAs, provides delivery tracking, and collects delivery feedback.
7 Menu Psychology Tricks to Boost Sales and Average Order Value
Use Decoy Pricing to Encourage Upselling
Decoy pricing is a powerful menu psychology tactic that can significantly boost your average order value. The concept is simple: include a slightly less appealing item next to your target dish. The decoy item should be priced similarly to the target dish but with fewer features or less desirable attributes.
For example, if you want to push a $25 steak entrée, place a $23 chicken dish with smaller sides next to it on the menu. Customers will perceive the steak as a better value in comparison, making them more likely to choose it over the chicken. This subtle manipulation can lead to increased sales of your higher-priced items.
Implementing Decoy Pricing
Identify your target high-profit dishes
Create decoy items with similar pricing but fewer features
Place decoy items next to target dishes on the menu
Monitor sales data to gauge the effectiveness of your decoy pricing strategy
Leverage the Power of Nostalgia and Comfort Food
Nostalgia is a strong emotional trigger that can greatly influence customer behavior. By featuring familiar, comforting dishes on your menu, you tap into positive memories and create a sense of warmth and satisfaction. This emotional connection can lead to increased sales and customer loyalty.
Consider incorporating regional favorites or childhood classics into your menu. For instance, a homestyle mac and cheese or a classic apple pie can evoke feelings of comfort and familiarity. When customers associate your restaurant’s branding with positive emotions, they are more likely to return and spend more on each visit.
New Food
79% of Millennials and 78% of Gen X enjoy experimenting with products from different cultures or countries. Younger demographics are more open to trying new menu items.
Incorporating Nostalgia and Comfort Food
Research popular regional and childhood favorite dishes
Develop recipes that capture the essence of these nostalgic meals
Feature these items prominently on your menu with enticing descriptions
Use evocative language and imagery to enhance the emotional appeal
Create a Sense of Scarcity and Exclusivity
Scarcity is a powerful psychological driver that can create a sense of urgency and increase perceived value. By highlighting limited-time offers or seasonal specials on your menu, you encourage customers to act quickly and make a purchase before the opportunity is gone.
Use phrases like “while supplies last” or “limited quantity” to emphasize the scarcity of certain items. This tactic works particularly well with seasonal ingredients or special promotions. Customers are more likely to order these items and even pay a premium for the exclusive experience.
Implementing Scarcity and Exclusivity
Identify seasonal ingredients or unique menu items
Create limited-time offers or seasonal specials featuring these items
Use language that emphasizes scarcity and exclusivity on the menu
Promote these offers through social media and in-store signage
The Most Common Types of Menus
When it comes to restaurant menus, there are several common types used in different settings. Here’s a quick overview:
À la carte: Customers choose individual dishes from a list of options. This is the most common type of menu in sit-down restaurants.
Prix fixe: A fixed-price menu where customers pay a set amount for a multi-course meal. Often used in fine dining establishments.
Cycle: A menu that changes regularly, often featuring seasonal ingredients. Commonly used in fast-casual and upscale restaurants.
Static: A menu that remains the same for an extended period. Most common in fast food and chain restaurants.
By understanding and employing these menu psychology tricks, you can effectively boost sales, increase average order value, and drive profits in your restaurant. Experiment with different tactics and monitor your results to find the perfect formula for your unique establishment.
Maximizing Profits: 5 High-Profit Menu Items to Feature
When it comes to increasing your restaurant’s profitability, featuring high-profit menu items is a crucial strategy. By strategically showcasing dishes and beverages with low food costs and high perceived value, you can significantly improve your average order value and overall revenue. Discover templates for restaurant menus to beautifully present your high-profit items and enhance your revenue with our free resources.
Pasta Dishes
Pasta dishes are a top choice for maximizing profits in your restaurant. With relatively low food costs and high perceived value, these meals can be a real winner for your bottom line. Pasta is also incredibly versatile, allowing you to customize dishes to suit different tastes and dietary preferences.
According to Chef Tony Mantuano, owner of Spiaggia in Chicago, “Pasta is a great way to maximize profits because it’s inexpensive to make and can be sold at a premium price. You can create a variety of dishes with different sauces and ingredients to keep your menu fresh and exciting.”
Customization and Upselling Opportunities
One of the key advantages of pasta dishes is the ease of customization. By offering a range of sauces, toppings, and protein options, you can cater to various preferences and dietary needs. This customization also presents opportunities for upselling, as customers may be willing to pay more for premium ingredients or larger portions.
As noted by restaurant consultant Mark Laux, “Pasta dishes offer a great opportunity for upselling. You can charge extra for adding proteins like chicken or shrimp, or for using premium ingredients like truffle oil or fresh herbs. These small additions can significantly increase the profitability of each dish.”
Pizza
Pizza is another highly profitable menu item that can help boost your restaurant’s bottom line. With high-profit margins, especially when featuring premium toppings, pizza is a popular choice among diners and can be easily customized to suit different tastes.
Industry expert and founder of Pizza Today, Steve Green, states, “Pizza has always been a profitable menu item for restaurants. The key is to offer a variety of toppings and crusts to appeal to a wide range of customers. By using premium ingredients and charging accordingly, you can significantly increase your profit margins.”
Upselling with Add-Ons and Variations
Pizza presents numerous opportunities for upselling and increasing the average order value. By offering add-ons like extra toppings, specialty cheeses, or dipping sauces, you can encourage customers to spend more on their orders. Additionally, featuring different crust options and sizes can help cater to various preferences and appetites.
As mentioned by Gina Pantely, a restaurant marketing expert, “Offering a range of pizza variations and add-ons is a great way to increase profits. Customers are often willing to pay more for personalized options, and these small extras can add up quickly to boost your bottom line.”
addıng healthy and convenıent optıons
61% of diners say they are more likely to eat healthy at a restaurant than they were two years ago.
55% of consumers say they'd order breakfast items at any time if they were offered. Diners love the convenience of all-day breakfast.
51% of consumers are more likely to visit a restaurant that offers environmentally-friendly food items.
Cocktails and Alcoholic Beverages
Cocktails and alcoholic beverages are often the most profitable items on a restaurant menu. With high markup potential and the ability to drive impulse purchases, featuring a strong beverage program can significantly contribute to your overall revenue.
According to mixologist and consultant Brian Van Flandern, “Cocktails are a great way to increase profits in a restaurant. The markup on alcohol is typically much higher than on food, and customers are often willing to pay a premium for a well-crafted drink. By creating signature cocktails and offering a diverse selection, you can boost your bottom line.”
Signature Drinks and Creative Presentations
To maximize the profitability of your cocktail program, focus on developing signature drinks that showcase your restaurant’s unique style and creativity. By crafting memorable and visually appealing beverages, you can create a buzz around your offerings and encourage customers to share their experiences on social media.
As emphasized by bar expert and author David Kaplan, “Signature cocktails are a great way to differentiate your restaurant and create a memorable experience for customers. By using premium ingredients, unique flavor combinations, and creative presentations, you can justify higher prices and increase your profits.”
most profıtable ıtems
Pizza: With an average gross profit margin of 85%, pizza is a highly profitable item due to its versatility and ability to be customized with various toppings.
Drinks: Drinks, especially marked-up beverages like fountain drinks and mixed cocktails, can contribute significantly to a restaurant's profit margin.
Appetizers: Generally inexpensive to make, appetizers can be a high-profit item, especially when offered in big platters to attract groups.
Mastering Menu Design: Tips for an Irresistible Menu Layout
After optimizing your menu offerings to include high-profit items, the next step is to focus on menu design and layout. A well-designed menu not only showcases your dishes but also subtly guides customers toward making favorable choices for your business. By implementing proven design principles and psychology-backed techniques, you can create irresistible and profitable menu items that boost your average order value and overall profitability.
Use High-Quality Images to Showcase Your Dishes
Visuals play a crucial role in enticing customers and influencing their ordering decisions. Investing in professional food photography can make a significant impact on your menu’s appeal and effectiveness.
Invest in Professional Food Photography
Hire a skilled food photographer to capture your dishes in the best possible light. High-quality images that showcase the texture, colors, and presentation of your menu items can make them more appealing and desirable to customers. Professional photos also help to establish trust and credibility, as they demonstrate your commitment to quality and attention to detail.
Place Images Strategically to Draw Attention to High-Profit Items
When incorporating images into your menu design, be strategic about their placement. Position photos of your high-profit items in prominent locations, such as the top right corner of the menu or near the center of the page. Studies have shown that customers tend to focus more on these areas when scanning a menu, making them prime spots for featuring your most profitable dishes.
Additionally, consider using larger images or visual cues, like boxes or highlights, to further emphasize these high-profit items and draw customers’ attention to them.
Optimize Your Menu’s Typography and Color Scheme
The typography and color scheme you choose for your menu can greatly influence its readability, aesthetic appeal, and overall impact on customers’ ordering behavior.
Choose Legible Fonts and a Clean Layout
Opt for clear, easy-to-read fonts that align with your restaurant’s brand identity. Avoid overly decorative or script fonts that may be difficult to decipher, as this can frustrate customers and slow down the ordering process. Stick to a maximum of two or three font families throughout your menu to maintain a cohesive and professional look.
Ensure that your online menu layout is clean and well-organized, with clear section headers and ample white space between items. This makes it easier for customers to navigate the menu and find the dishes they desire.
Menu Design
A menu is not just a list of dishes but a key factor in designing a restaurant’s marketing plan. It acts like an advertising tool that can showcase the restaurant’s identity and increase the profit level. A well-designed menu enhances the dining experience of customers.
Use Colors to Evoke the Desired Mood and Highlight Specific Items
Color psychology plays a significant role in restaurant menu design. Choose colors that align with your restaurant’s concept and evoke the desired emotional response from your customers. For example, warm colors like red and orange can stimulate appetite, while cool colors like blue and green can create a calming atmosphere.
Use color strategically to highlight your high-profit items or special offerings. By incorporating subtle color cues, such as a different background color or border, you can draw customers’ attention to these dishes without being overtly promotional.
Digital Menus
Using digital menu boards can result in an annual gain of $16,000 in in-store sales per unit. Digital menus allow for easy updates and upselling.
Scanning Time
Customers tend to scan menus quickly, spending an average of just 109 seconds.
Incorporate Storytelling and Dish Descriptions
Engaging customers emotionally through storytelling and enticing dish descriptions can significantly impact their ordering decisions and overall experience.
Provide Enticing Descriptions that Showcase Ingredients and Preparation Methods
Craft compelling dish descriptions that go beyond just a list of a simple list of ingredients. Use sensory language to highlight the flavors, textures, and aromas of each item, making them more appealing and memorable to customers. Incorporate information about the origin of key ingredients, unique preparation methods, or the inspiration behind the dish to create a deeper connection with your customers.
Well-written descriptions can also help to justify higher price points for your high-profit items, as customers will perceive added value in the quality and care put into each dish.
Use Storytelling to Create an Emotional Connection with Your Dishes
Infuse your menu with elements of storytelling to create a more engaging and memorable dining experience. Share the history behind signature dishes, highlight the cultural significance of certain ingredients and cuisine, or showcase the passion and expertise of your culinary team. By weaving stories throughout your menu, you create an emotional bond with your customers, making them more likely to order items that resonate with them on a personal level.
Storytelling can also help to differentiate your restaurant from competitors and establish a unique brand identity that customers will remember and return for.
By mastering menu design and layout, you can create an irresistible menu that not only showcases your dishes but also strategically guides customers toward making profitable ordering decisions. Combining high-quality visuals, optimized typography, color schemes, and engaging storytelling, you’ll be well on your way to skyrocketing your average order value and overall restaurant success.
5 Popular Restaurant Menu Ideas and When to Use Them
À la Carte Menus
À la carte menus are a classic choice for restaurants that offer a wide variety of dishes and want to give customers the freedom to customize their meals. This menu format lists each item separately, along with its price, allowing diners to create their combinations. À la carte menus are particularly well-suited for fine dining establishments, where guests expect a high level of flexibility and personalization.
One of the main advantages of à la carte menus is that they allow restaurants to showcase their culinary expertise and creativity. Chefs can craft unique dishes and ideas that highlight their skills and the quality of their ingredients, without being constrained by a fixed menu structure. This format also enables restaurants to cater to different dietary preferences and restrictions, as customers can easily mix and match items to suit their needs.
When to Use À la Carte Menus
-
Fine dining restaurants with a focus on culinary innovation and personalization
-
Establishments with a diverse customer base and varied dietary requirements
-
Restaurants with a wide range of offerings, including appetizers, entrees, sides, and desserts
Prix Fixe Menus
Prix fixe menus, also known as set menus, offer a predetermined selection of courses at a fixed price. This format is ideal for special occasions, themed events, or restaurants that want to streamline their operations and reduce food waste. By offering a limited number of options, prix fixe menus allow chefs to plan, optimize ingredient usage, and maintain consistent quality.
Prix fixe menus can also be an effective tool for upselling and increasing average order value. By bundling courses together at an attractive price point, restaurants can encourage customers to try new dishes and spend more than they might with an à la carte menu. Additionally, prix fixe menus can create a sense of value and exclusivity, making diners feel like they’re getting a special dining experience.
When to Use Prix Fixe Menus
-
Restaurants hosting special events, such as holiday dinners or wine-pairing evenings
-
Establishments looking to streamline operations and reduce food waste
-
Eateries aiming to create a unique dining experience or showcase a specific culinary theme
Cycle Menus
Cycle menus also referred to as rotating menus, are an excellent choice for restaurants that want to keep their offerings fresh and exciting for regular customers. This format of a restaurant website involves changing a portion of the menu regularly, such as weekly or seasonally, while maintaining a core set of popular dishes. Cycle menus allow chefs to showcase seasonal ingredients, test new recipes, and adapt to changing customer preferences.
One of the key benefits of cycle menus is that they encourage repeat visits from loyal customers who are eager to try new dishes. By regularly updating the most seasonal menu here, restaurants can create a sense of anticipation and excitement, keeping diners engaged and coming back for more. Cycle menus also provide an opportunity for chefs to experiment with new flavors and techniques, while minimizing the risk of investing in dishes that may not resonate with customers.
Updating Menus
31% of restaurateurs update their menu on a monthly basis, while 24% do it seasonally. 88% of restaurant operators plan to expand their menu offerings in the next year. Popular new menu trends include global flavors, zero-waste cooking, and healthy kids meals.
When to Use Cycle Menus
Restaurants with a strong focus on seasonal ingredients and locally sourced produce
Establishments catering to a loyal customer base that values variety and novelty
Eateries looking to test new dishes and gather customer feedback before making permanent menu changes
Buffet Menus
Buffet menus offer a wide variety of dishes in a self-service format, where customers can serve themselves from a selection of options. This format is well-suited for restaurants that want to provide a casual, relaxed dining experience and cater to large groups or families. Buffet menus often include a mix of hot and cold dishes, salads, and desserts.
One of the main advantages of buffet menus is that they allow customers to try a variety of dishes without committing to a single entree. This format also enables restaurants to offer a high volume of food at a lower cost per item, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious diners. Additionally, buffet menus can be an effective way to reduce food waste, as customers can serve themselves the exact amount they want.
When to Use Buffet Menus
Restaurants catering to large groups or families
Establishments looking to offer a casual, relaxed dining experience
Eateries aiming to provide a high volume of food at a lower cost per item
Combination Menus
Combination menus combine elements of different menu formats to create a unique dining experience. For example, a restaurant might offer a prix fixe menu with à la carte options or a cycle menu with a buffet component. This format allows chefs to showcase their creativity and flexibility while providing customers with a range of choices.
One of the key benefits of combination menus is that they can cater to a diverse customer base with varying preferences and dietary needs. By offering a mix of menu formats, restaurants can appeal to a broader audience and increase customer satisfaction. Combination menus also provide an opportunity for chefs to experiment with new dishes and flavors, while minimizing the risk of investing in a single menu format.
When to Use Combination Menus
Restaurants with a diverse customer base and varied dietary requirements
Establishments looking to showcase their culinary creativity and flexibility
Eateries aiming to cater to a broad audience and increase customer satisfaction
What is Menu Engineering and Why is it Important?
Definition of Menu Engineering
Menu engineering is the strategic process of analyzing and optimizing a restaurant’s menu to maximize profitability and popularity. It involves studying customer behavior, food costs, and sales data to make informed decisions about menu design, item placement, and pricing. Unlock the secret to boosting your restaurant’s success by mastering how to craft a menu that not only appeals to your patrons but significantly increases your profitability.
By leveraging menu engineering techniques, restaurants can highlight their most profitable dishes, guide customers toward high-margin items, and create a more appealing and effective menu. This data-driven approach helps restaurateurs make smart decisions that boost their bottom line and enhance the overall dining experience for their customers.
Menu Engineering
Ongoing menu engineering has the potential to increase restaurant profits by 10-15%. Menu engineering can help restaurants maximize profitability by identifying high-margin and popular dishes.
It can also help reduce waste and lower restaurant costs by identifying low-performing items.
The Science Behind Menu Design
Menu engineering combines the art of design with the science of psychology and economics. Researchers have found that customers typically scan a menu in a predictable pattern, known as the “golden triangle.” This pattern starts at the center of the menu, moves to the top right, and then settles on the top left. By placing high-margin items in these prime locations, restaurants can draw attention to their most profitable dishes. Uncover the key factors in crafting a menu for a restaurant, including how to strategically place high-profit items to enhance visibility and sales.
Benefits of Menu Engineering
Implementing menu engineering strategies can provide numerous benefits for restaurants, including:
-
Increased Profitability: By promoting high-margin dishes and optimizing menu design, restaurants can encourage customers to order items that contribute more to their bottom line. Even small changes in menu item placement or pricing can lead to significant improvements in profitability over time.
-
Improved Customer Satisfaction: Menu engineering helps restaurants showcase their most popular and well-received dishes. By featuring items that customers love, restaurants can enhance the dining experience and build a loyal customer base.
-
Streamlined Kitchen Operations: By analyzing sales data and optimizing the menu, restaurants can better predict demand for certain dishes. This allows them to adjust inventory levels, reduce waste, and ensure that the kitchen staff is prepared to execute the most popular menu items efficiently.
Key Metrics in Menu Engineering
To effectively implement menu engineering strategies, restaurateurs must understand and track several key metrics:
Food Cost Percentage
Food cost percentage is the ratio of the cost of ingredients to the selling price of a menu item. By monitoring this metric, restaurants can ensure that they are pricing their dishes appropriately to maintain profitability. Ideally, the food cost percentage should be between 28-35% for most menu items.
Contribution Margin
Contribution margin is the difference between the selling price of a menu item and its variable costs, such as ingredients and packaging. This metric helps restaurants identify which menu items are most profitable and should be promoted most profitable menu items. High-margin items should be strategically placed on the menu to encourage customer purchases. Integrating a menu design software can help ensure these high-margin items are presented in a visually compelling and effective way.
Menu Item Popularity
Tracking the popularity of menu items is crucial for understanding customer preferences and optimizing the menu. By analyzing sales data, restaurants can identify their best-selling dishes and make informed decisions about which items to keep, modify, or remove from the menu.
Sales Mix Analysis
Sales mix analysis involves restaurant menu templates evaluating the percentage of total sales generated by each menu category (e.g., appetizers, entrees, desserts) or individual menu items. This analysis helps restaurants understand which areas of the menu are performing well and which may need improvement. By optimizing the sales mix, restaurants can boost overall profitability.
Putting Menu Engineering into Practice
To put menu engineering principles into action, restaurants should follow these steps:
-
Conduct a thorough analysis of sales data and food costs to identify high-performing and low-performing menu items.
-
Evaluate the menu design and layout to ensure that high-margin items are prominently featured and strategically placed. Additionally, consider using a menu maker tool to experiment with innovative designs and layouts that draw attention to key menu items.
-
Experiment with menu item descriptions, pricing, and placement to influence customer behavior and encourage sales of high-margin items.
-
Regularly review and update the menu based on sales data and customer feedback to ensure ongoing optimization and profitability.
By mastering the art and science of menu engineering, restaurants, and restaurant owners can make data-driven decisions that improve profitability, customer satisfaction, and overall business success.
Maximizing Your Menu’s Potential
By implementing these menu ideas and hacks, you can significantly boost your restaurant’s average order value and profitability. From strategic menu engineering to leveraging menu psychology tricks, featuring high-profit items, and optimizing your menu design, these strategies work together to create an irresistible dining experience for your customers.
By focusing on these key areas, you can drive sales, increase customer satisfaction, and ultimately, grow your business. Start by analyzing your current menu’s performance, identifying areas for improvement, and gradually incorporating these proven techniques.
Remember, your menu is your most powerful sales tool. Investing time and effort into crafting a well-designed, psychologically compelling menu will pay off in the long run.
Which menu hack do you plan to implement first in your restaurant?
